PJ Hanley's Tavern 449 Court St, Brooklyn, NY11231 Known to be the oldest bar in Brooklyn, according to management, PJ Hanley's Tavern is the current incarnation of a pub…More dating to 1874. Photos of the bar and Brooklyn's history adorn one of the walls. A large garden area offers additional seating. Patrons can dine on burgers and traditional bar food or order from South Brooklyn Pizza next door, which share the same owner.
South Brooklyn Pizza 451 Court St, Brooklyn, NY11231 This coal-oven pizzeria has two separate sections: a small take-out section with no seating and a more spacious bar area…More with tables and booths. The pies come in three varieties, and there is a different special pie made each Tuesday night. Both sections are connected to the bar next door, PJ Hanley's.