Carroll Gardens Homeless Shelter Meets With Resistant Neighbors at CB6 Forum

After various criticisms and questions, the committee called for DHS to reject the proposal on the basis of lack of process and merit.


A meeting held Wednesday night to discuss the proposed homeless shelter in Carroll Gardens did little to ease residents' many fears, issues and concerns with the prospect of these new neighbors moving into the community. 

Hosted by Community Board 6's Youth and Human Services Committee at , the meeting was filled to capacity with concerned residents and elected officials as well as representatives from Housing Solutions/Aguila, Inc. and the NYC's Dept. of Homeless Services to discuss what the neighborhood could expect. 

Robert Hess, CEO of Housing Solutions/Aguila, Inc., the non-profit that submitted the proposal to the Department of Homeless Services (DHS) plans to open a shelter that will house 170 single men at 165 W. 9 St., formerly prepared as a 10-unit condo building. Hess noted he has considerable experience in running homeless services, and that the decision to open a shelter in Carroll Gardens was one of opportunity. 

"We constantly monitor demand for shelters," Hess said. "From our perspective it was a very good facility to house single adults."

After deciding on the building, Housing Solutions/Aguila made the City aware of the facility and authorities came to look and agreed it was suitable, he said. 

"We made a proposal to the City to house 170 single men in that facility," Hess continued. "We expect a significant security force, case managers, record and supervisors and specialists on sight."

Alex Zablocki, a spokesman for the DHS, agreed with Hess, saying the shelter will house employable men who will be allowed to stay at the facility for six months to a year on average.

Though board members stressed that the meeting was strictly informational, many residents and elected officials wanted more than the answers and explanations provided. 

Assemblywoman Joan Millman, State Senator Daniel Squadron and Councilman Brad Lander were in agreement that all New Yorkers should have a safe place to sleep at night. But all three stated they felt the way this particular case was handled by parties involved was not "collaborative, thoughtful, or well conceived."

Elected officials reminded the community and those representing DHS that they, along with Borough President Marty Markowitz, had reached out to Seth Diamond, the Commissioner of the DHS, asking to be part of the process to develop an "appropriate proposal" to bring a homeless shelter to the neighborhood, and raised questions that many at the meeting had been asking all night.

Some questions asked include, why this process has seemingly been done through a "side-door" process, how it will be possible to fit 170 people into a 10-unit building, why construction crews are already working on the building, why neither a security proposal nor a service plan were provided to the public and those elected officials, and why the DHS has not addressed potential conflicts of interest, as noted by Capital New York

Zablocki stated that this process is being done through the “emergency contract” rule which allows for an expedited process, and that the agency must offer a bed to every individual that comes for one under State mandate. 

The backgrounds of individuals that will be living in the shelter came up often, with many residents concerned that criminals and otherwise deviant individuals will be coming to the neighborhood.

Zablocki didn't quell fears when he explained that the "Right to Shelter" policy doesn't disqualify those with a criminal record. In fact, individuals do not have to disclose their past during the 21-day evaluation period conducted at a different location. "They are coming to us because they don't have any other options," he said.

Zablocki noted that the New York State Office Of Temporary Disability Assistance (OTDA) will make the final decision whether 165 W. 9 Street is a suitable location for a facility, and told residents they can continue to direct their concerns to DHS at externalaffairs@dhs.nyc.gov. 

Following the public information meeting, the Youth and Human Services Committee unanimously passed a motion that noted Community Board 6 opposes the use of 165 W. 9th St. for a 170-bed homeless shelter for 170 men. The motion called for DHS to reject the proposal on the basis of lack of process and merit.

The motion will be voted on by the full Community Board at the next general meeting.

Frank Cuomo October 27, 2012 at 09:23 PM
Keeping things simple, everyone deserves a safe place to sleep but where were our elected officials when this deal was being negotiated? Who was looking out for the mddle class residents during the execution of this deal? No advance communication or fanfare to the community. We have to deal with a potential crime increase as a result of these homeless folks being in the area on top of the recent crime activity that has taken place over the past few months. What else are we expected to accept as part of the status quo to live in our community? It seems that we may have more questions then answers.
August Jones November 07, 2012 at 12:20 AM
Will all the residents around this shelter be ABSOLUTELY SOBER & DRUG-FREE?
oznek November 26, 2012 at 01:02 PM
No not all some maybe might take drugs but maybe? not or maybe yes they may mug you. ..or maybe not who knows we couldn't get any straight answers all night. ..maybe 170 maybe 200 ...maybe ex-cons maybe not maybe good security maybe a curfew at 10 pm or maybe not. .....maybe maybe I dun know da


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something