patching...
Breaking: P.S. 58 on Bed Bug Alert »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Update: Disturbing the Peace: Bergen St. Residents Say Gallery Parties Too Loud

Residents are angry over local art galleries hosting loud events late into the night, but the galleries say they're not disrupting anyone.

 

Update, Nov. 9: This article has been revised to include comments about Chaos Manor from Invisible Dog owner Lucien Zayan.

On Friday and Saturday nights on Bergen Street in Boerum Hill, residents know to close their windows and turn up the TV to block the din from outside.

The music and noise resulting from a trend in area art galleries hosting loud parties has all but ruined any chance at weekend peace and relaxation, they say.

“It's impossible to hear the conversation in the house with all this noise," says Vicky Vossen, a Bergen Street resident who is helping organize neighbors to stop the loud events. 

But Lucien Zayan, director of the Invisible Dog Art Center at 51 Bergen St., called the complaints “out of proportion.”

“We strive not to bother our neighbors and to be a good neighbor,” he said. “We’re very involved with our neighborhood and support local artists here.”

In the past twelve months, he said, his gallery has hosted half a dozen wedding receptions – the only special events where music is played. According to Zayan, music is not played at frequent art gallery openings.

But residents said they’ve experienced the noise far more often. Frequent calls to 311 and area police have not resolved the issue, they say, as noise complaints are not a high priority. A special Community Board 2 meeting to address the noise issues has been postponed until later this month or early December.

The Invisible Dog and Muriel Guepin art galleries are located in a 30,000 square-foot former warehouse on Bergen Street. The factory sat empty for more than a decade before the owner, Frank DeFalco, purchased the property and installed new businesses a few years ago. The galleries host art exhibitions, musical performances and artists’ studios.

Last year, the galleries began renting out the spaces for special events like weddings and bat/bar mitzvahs to raise extra cash. The galleries do not have soundproof walls or air conditioning – a raucous combination when overheated event-goers open the windows to get fresh air, spilling loud music onto the street.

 “We appreciate what they’re trying to do with the building and creating an artists’ space,” said Dean Street resident Chris Peters, who lives in an apartment building across from the Invisible Dog's parking lot. “It’s just unfortunate that in order to pay their rent they’re hosting these events that hurt the quality of life for people in the area.”

DeFalco is traveling abroad and could not be reached for comment.

Zayan said DeFalco is working on the problem and will soon install air conditioning and soundproof walls. In the meantime, he said, the gallery has someone on staff during events to ensure the windows are closed and people are not loitering outside.

Councilmember Stephen Levin, who represents Boerum Hill, said the noise problems on Bergen Street aren’t unique to the neighborhood – rather, they’re found throughout the city, especially in flourishing artist communities.

“The creative spirit of Boerum Hill and the numerous nearby cultural institutions are what made this neighborhood a draw for so many residents, but there needs to be a balance between the lively arts community and the rights of all residents to enjoy peace and quiet,” Levin said.

In September, the City Council voted to approve a rezoning to preserve the neighborhood's brownstone character. The rezoning was an initiative by the Boerum Hill Association and halted DeFalco's construction plans to add additional artist space onto the buildings. There has also been some talk about creating a Bergen Street "arts district."

Residents insisted they welcome local artists and the galleries into their neighborhood. What they can’t stand is loud partying and noise masquerading as art.

The last straw, they said, was a two-day event held Sept. 16 and 17 called Chaos Manor, a performance installation where artists Christopher McElroen and Sam Stephenson attempted to recreate photographer W. Eugene Smith’s “jazz loft” project. The famed World War II photographer took more than 40,000 photos of jazz musicians playing live at his Manhattan loft apartment from 1957 to 1965.

The Chaos Manor event was supported by the Boerum Hill Association and was a bookend to the Brooklyn Book Festival.

According to an event press release, “Chaos Manor will be staged within the 22 exterior windows and on the building façade of The Invisible Dog with the audience on the street below. Using the building itself as an instrument…layers of recorded sound and live music will be woven through 22 exterior windows.”

Residents, including some parents of young children, compared the event to a rave with loud music emanating from the building into the wee hours of night and people dancing and yelling on Bergen Street. When repeated calls to 311 did not solve the problem, Peters took video of the party scene and noise to show police later.

"We never did a 'rave party'" said Zayan. "Chaos Manor is a true artistic project, produced by established writers, directors and producers."

Though neighbors had complained amongst themselves before, Chaos Manor banded them together in their calls for a community meeting with DeFalco and the gallery directors.

“Beyond a certain hour, the strobe lights and the noise – it’s unconscionable,” Peters said.

Upon hearing of residents’ complaints, Zayan circulated a letter of support from Bergen Street residents who don’t find the Invisible Dog disruptive. On the contrary, the letter states, the Invisible Dog is a positive asset to the local community that adds cultural and artistic value to the area. Thirty-five people signed the letter.

Levin says the groups have to find a way to live together.

“I hope that by working together and engaging in a constructive dialogue, we can find a suitable compromise that meets the needs of Bergen Street residents and allows Invisible Dog to continue to support local artists.”

Related Topics: 61 local, Bergen Street, Invisible Dog Art Gallery, Muriel Guepin Gallery, Noise, and Steve Levin

Steven Coburn

6:49 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

There is no compromise when it comes to noise. If they must play music, the Gallery should move into a 100% commercial area and get out of the residential area. Period. Why isn't zoning more strictly enforced to prevent these kinds of clashes?

Reply

spnder

10:17 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

Attention Bergen Street residents. Chaos Manor was like a "rave?" You have got to be kidding me. It was a loud mess of a performance art piece, but as I stood out front with my friends, I was thinking "What an amazing neighborhood that allows this to happen." As I recall it went on for about an hour and ended before 10pm. To call it a rave is certainly hyperbole. Of course the noise issues should be addressed, but not at the expense of chilling what little artistic expression exists in our neighborhood.

Reply

Frank Amoss

7:40 pm on Monday, November 7, 2011

I attended the event at the Invisible Dog on Sept. 16. The two numbers played by the jazz quartet (unamplified) were not obtrusive and the crowd was polite and attentive. There was no dancing in the streets. The event lasted less than an hour and was concluded before 9:00 pm. Whoever compared the proceedings to a rave must be completely intolerant of any artistic expression and a bad judge of human behavior.

Frank Amoss

Reply

terryl simeina

1:34 pm on Wednesday, November 9, 2011

i live on bergen street and attended the event described above and the writer really should've interviewed a few more residents to get a mix of opinions prior to publishing this article. comparing the event to a rave is completely ridiculous. there was absolutely no loud music emanating from the building or dancing on bergen street into the wee hours of the night. clearly, the individuals interviewed have no concept of what constitutes a rave. i have lived on the block for over 7 years and the invisible dog and guepin art gallery are both positive additions to the block. its ashamed that a few residents have resorted to these exaggerations because they, for some reason, dislike the improvements made to the block.

Reply

Risa

4:25 pm on Wednesday, November 9, 2011

The Invisible Dog is a hugely positive addition to this neighborhood and to Brooklyn. It has created jobs, workspace for artists and brought in visitors from other neighborhoods (and boroughs!) to Carroll Gardens where they are likely to explore and spend their money. The tone of the article is somewhat incendiary. Mr. Zayan is a good neighbor - making sure he is on friendly terms with the schools (for whom he hosts benefits) and other businesses on Bergen Street. I have observed him asking renters and artists in his venue to be mindful of their noise so as not to disturb the ID's neighbors. I am sure this matter can and will be resolved.

Reply

Dorrie Woodson

12:55 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

I visited the IDAC on September 16th. I arrived about one and a half hours early and went inside to look at the exhibitions. I want to begin by saying that I am 77 y.o. and avoid high volumes like the plague. I walked around and enjoyed the exhibitions, and then sat down and looked around as people were walking about seemingly enjoying being part of the whole event. I was not at all uncomfortable with the volume level. People were simply in high spirits as one would expect at a similar social event. At the scheduled time, I went outside to watch "Chaos Manor', and although I don't know Mr. Amoss, I am in total agreement with all his observations. The crowd was really absorbed in watching the presentation on the backdrop of the building. At the end of the presentation, the audience applauded enthusiastically. There was no dancing in the street. People milled about meeting new people, and to my delight, I met a person I hadn't seen in about 55 years. It was a great evening for me, and at no time did I have difficulty hearing the person I was talking with. The crowd gradually thinned out. In closing, I only know about this one evening, but I have great difficulty understanding what all the fuss concerning noise is about. P.S. I want to add that Mr. Stephenson was gracious enough BEFORE the CM performance, in the middle of the tensions of last minute preparations, to have a photo taken with me. I just want to add my voice by giving 5 stars to the whole evening's happenings.

Reply

Leave a comment